Jane: "I just can't get this take-home exam done! It is just to hard for me! I'm going to call Joan and get the answers from her. She got an 'A' on it when she took the class."
Kelly: "Jane, you shouldn't do that. You know cheating is wrong. Also, Professor Gordon lets you guys take the exam home because he trusts that you will be honest. Betraying his trust is even worse than cheating."
Jane: 'You are one to talk. "
Kelly: 'What do you mean?"
Jane: "Last Saturday, when we were drinking, you told me that you cheated on your boyfriend when you were seventeen."
Kelly: "So?"
Jane: 'Well, you must be wrong when you say cheating and betrayal is wrong. After all, you did it. So it must be okay."Personal AttackPoisoning the WellAd Hominem Tu QuoqueAppeal to Common PracticePersonal Attack: This is a wrong answer. Jane is not attempting to reject a claim Kelly has made because of an attack against some characteristic of Kelly that Jane does not like. Since Jane wants to cheat, it is very unlikely that she is attacking Kelly on this issue.Poisoning the Well: This is a wrong answer. Jane is not attempting to discredit Kelly's claim in advance of anything Kelly has to say.Ad Hominem Tu Quoque: This is the right answer. Jane rejects Kelly's claim that cheating and betrayal are wrong by asserting that Kelly has done both. Her "reasoning" is that it can't be wrong because Kelly cheated and betrayed too.Appeal to Common Practice: This is a wrong answer. Jane is attempting to reject Kelly's claim because of something Kelly did, not because it is a common practice. Since there was no mention of anyone besides Kelly, Jane, and Gordon, it is fairly clear that no appeal to a practice that is accepted by many people is being made by Jane.Jane is trying to reject Kelly's claim because of something Kelly did in the past.3